SPCH 3710 Chapter 9 I.Attitude focused studies A.Concept of Attitude 1.Thomas & Znaniecki (1927) - "By attitude we understand a process of individual consciousness which determines real or possible activity of the individual in the social world." 2.Allport (1954) - " a mental and neural state of readiness, organized through experience, exerting a directive or dynamic influence upon the individual's responses." 3.Rosenberg & Hovland (1960) - an attitude has 3 components a.affective component - feeling toward something b.cognitive component - verbal statements of belief c.behavioral component - overt actions B.Hovland’s Army Research - believed that attitudes were learned and were changed through the same processes that occurred when learning took place. 1.He lead research of 2 basic types a.evaluation of existing films b.experimental studies in which two different versions of the same film (or message) were compared 2.They determined the film’s impact in 3 main areas a.specific factual knowledge gained from the film b.specific opinions concerning the Battle of Britain c.factual acceptance of the military role and willingness to fight C.One-sided & Two-sided messages 1.One-sided works better with persons initially favorable to the message and those with less education 2.Two-sided works most effective with persons initially opposed to the message and those with greater education II.The Yale Communication Research Program (Hovland, Janis, & Kelly, 1953) A.Three characteristics of the project 1.concerned with theoretical issues and basic research 2.it drew upon theoretical developments from diverse sources within psychology and related fields 3.emphasized testing propositions by controlled experiment B.Source credibility 1.Hovland & Weiss (1951) - designed an experiment to test the effectiveness of source credibility 2.Horai, Naccari, & Fatoullah (1974) - used the factors of expertise and attractiveness a.high, low, or no information - expertise b.high, low, or no photograph - attractiveness 1.the good looking were perceived to be smarter 2.more agreement with the high expertise source 3.Whitehead (1968) - objectivity and dynamism play a key role in persuasiveness. This concept was added to Hovland & Weiss’ notion of credibility coming from expertise. a.found 4 dominant factors in his study: trustworthiness, professionalism, dynamism, and objectivity. 4.Anderson (1971) - source credibility = a weight. That weight, which is determined by various characteristics of the source, amplifies the value of the message. C.Fear Appeals - threatens or arouses fear in receivers 1.Janis & Feshbach - dental hygiene fear experiment (minimal levels of fear were most effective) 2.Protection Motivation Theory Model - Rogers & Mewborn (1976) - 3 key elements a.magnitude of noxiousness of a depicted event b.probability of that event’s occurrence c.the efficacy of a protective response III.Inoculation Theory A.Definition of Inoculation - a deliberate exposure to a weakened form of a germ that stimulates the development of defenses. (medical) B.McGuire & Papageorgis’s (1961) - people may have many unchallenged beliefs and these beliefs may be easily swayed because a person is not used to defending them. (i.e. cultural truisms) IV.Katz’s functional approach to attitude change A.Katz argues that both attitude formation and change must be understood in terms of the functions that attitudes serve for the personality B.Katz’s 4 functions attitudes can serve for the personality 1.instrumental, adjustive, utilitarian function 2.ego-defensive function 3.value-expressive function 4.knowledge function V. Attitudes & Behavior A.attitudes may not bear much influence upon behaviors 1.LaPiere - explored prejudiced ideas held around the U.S. 2.verbal reports don’t provide good predictors of actual behavior B.Festinger (1964) - inverse relationship between attitude change and behavior change C.Ajzen & Fishbein (1970) - Equation 1.A person’s intention to perform a given behavior is a function of: a.person’s attitude toward performing that behavior b.a person’s perception of the norms governing that behavior and the individual’s motivation to comply with those norms D.Two lines of recent research on attitude - behavior consistency 1.Fishbein approach - incorporates norms and other relevant variables in a predictive model 2.Weigel & Newman - attempts to predict from attitude to a range of behaviors rather than a single specific behavior E.Classical Conditioning of Attitudes 1.Staats & Staats (1968) - certain words are systematically paired with certain emotional experiences 2.Staats & Staats argue attitude is nothing more than an emotional meaning for a word that has been established by classical conditioning F.Low Involvement - Krugman - people process messages from TV differently than they do of messages in print 1.TV = low involvement, difficult to recall 2.TV is processed with the right hemisphere of the brain VI.Techniques of Persuasion A.Appeals to Humor 1.Duncan & Nelson (1985) - humor has more of an effect on low order communication effects. Humor is effective in attracting attention. 2.Festinger & Maccoby (1964) - learning theory approach - humor provides good reinforcement and thus a greater attitude change. 3.distraction approach - humor is distracting B.Appeals to Sex 1.Smith & Engel (1968) - a sexy model can affect the perception or image of a product even if there is very little connection made 2.Alexander & Judd (1978) - sexy models distract viewers attention away from the name of the product of company name 3.few studies show a positive influence on product recall when it comes to sex C.Repetition 1.better chance of being seen 2.better chance of being remembered 3.Krugman (1972) - only takes 3 good exposures to have desired effect a.cognitive response b.evaluative response c.reminder - beginning of disengagement D.New directions in Persuasion Theory 1.going towards a view that recognizes the active role of the receiver 2.Norman Anderson - says that attitude change is a result of the way individuals combine or integrate all the information available relevant to a given attitude object